http://www.christianpost.com/news/legal-expert-religious-clubs-have-no-case-against-vanderbilts-nondiscrimination-policy-68542/
I read this article and I am not surprised at the conclusion of the legal expert. Vanderbilt has decided that student organizations can not use religious beliefs to select their leaders. This means that Christian organizations can not disallow an atheist from a leadership position. Essentially, Vanderbilt wants to hide behind some corrupt notion of multiculturalism to squash religious expression.
I know that many religious organizations want to find legal ways to reverse the decisions of the Vanderbilt administration. I used to agree with them. But I realize that as a private institution they have the right to be bigots. So now I merely think that we should expose the Christianophobic desires of the Vanderbilt administration.
We should concede Vanderbilts' legal right. Years ago Bob Jones University prohibited interracial dating. They were wrong. But they had the legal right to do that. They are a private university and were free to practice racial bigotry. Likewise Vanderbilt is free to practice religious bigotry. Let them be stigmatized like Bob Jones University has been. That should be the price that Vanderbilt pays.
With this concession of Vanderbilt's rights I hope that progressives realize that this opens the door for other private educational institutions. When a Christian university passes rules that does not allow for an organization supporting homosexuals then I would expect the same individuals who turned their back on Christian organizations at Vanderbilt to acknowledge the rights of these Christian universities. To not do so would be hypocritical. And if they complain about these Christian universities then those complaints should fall on deaf ears. Only if you defend organizations that you disagree with do you have legitimacy to defend the organizations you do agree with.
So Vanderbilt, you are Bob Jones. Do not like that comparison? Too bad. If you act like a bigot then you should be seen as a bigot. You are a private institution and you have the legal right to crush religious expression. We have a right to see you for what you truly are.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Tuesday, April 17, 2012
Sunday, April 1, 2012
Internet Alterations
Recently I have completed collecting data on atheists. I have been curious about this group and this was an opportunity for me to satisfy that curiosity. I found it very interesting research and perhaps one day I will share some of the findings on this blog.
But this entry is not about the atheists. We collected data with an online survey where the respondent remained anonymous and another study where we used a face to face interview. What I found interesting is different ways the atheists reacted to us depending on how we collected our data. The answers from the online survey were quite derogatory towards religion in general and Christianity in particular. For example, one of the respondents wrote about Christians that we should “feed them to the lions.” The atheists we interviewed did not show much respect for religion but their comments were less caustic. They had opportunities to make derogatory comments but passed on those opportunities.
Why did they make more negative comments online than in person? Well it does not take an academic to figure that out. When we are writing the answer to a question to some unknown person we can be more hostile than when we are answering questions face to face, even though we may not know that person either. We were careful to not reveal our religious preferences when we did our interviews so for all the respondents knew we did not believe in the supernatural any more than they did. But it is still harder to be rude when you have to speak words to another person rather than write about killing religious out-groups.
Once again this is not about atheists. It is about the new ways we communicate with each other online. More and more the way we talk to each other is similar to the open ended questions that our atheists answered and not face to face as we did in our interviews. It may be that people are more honest when they can remain anonymous and online. But clearly they can also be more hostile and less respectful to others. Don’t believe me? Take a look at the comments section of a controversial online article. Depending on the topic you are likely to see examples of racism, anti-Christian bigotry, Islamophobia, Anti-Semitism, derogatory comments and insults of all types. People have a freedom to dehumanize and denigrate individuals when communicating in these discussion lists and you can see some really nasty stuff.
We have a polarized society and it is not surprising to see such hostile comments. But is this a reflection of the polarization in our society or has our online culture contributed to a new rude culture that we now live in? I tend to think that the latter is likely the case although I do not yet have any solid evidence that this is the case. If I am right then our internet culture is not only a tool for us but it is changing us and we may not like what we are changing into. Perhaps being online merely allows us to express our human nature which may have a natural tendency to denigrate those we disagree with. Regardless, we would be wise to continue to monitor our online culture and be aware of how it may change us or reveal who we really are.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
But this entry is not about the atheists. We collected data with an online survey where the respondent remained anonymous and another study where we used a face to face interview. What I found interesting is different ways the atheists reacted to us depending on how we collected our data. The answers from the online survey were quite derogatory towards religion in general and Christianity in particular. For example, one of the respondents wrote about Christians that we should “feed them to the lions.” The atheists we interviewed did not show much respect for religion but their comments were less caustic. They had opportunities to make derogatory comments but passed on those opportunities.
Why did they make more negative comments online than in person? Well it does not take an academic to figure that out. When we are writing the answer to a question to some unknown person we can be more hostile than when we are answering questions face to face, even though we may not know that person either. We were careful to not reveal our religious preferences when we did our interviews so for all the respondents knew we did not believe in the supernatural any more than they did. But it is still harder to be rude when you have to speak words to another person rather than write about killing religious out-groups.
Once again this is not about atheists. It is about the new ways we communicate with each other online. More and more the way we talk to each other is similar to the open ended questions that our atheists answered and not face to face as we did in our interviews. It may be that people are more honest when they can remain anonymous and online. But clearly they can also be more hostile and less respectful to others. Don’t believe me? Take a look at the comments section of a controversial online article. Depending on the topic you are likely to see examples of racism, anti-Christian bigotry, Islamophobia, Anti-Semitism, derogatory comments and insults of all types. People have a freedom to dehumanize and denigrate individuals when communicating in these discussion lists and you can see some really nasty stuff.
We have a polarized society and it is not surprising to see such hostile comments. But is this a reflection of the polarization in our society or has our online culture contributed to a new rude culture that we now live in? I tend to think that the latter is likely the case although I do not yet have any solid evidence that this is the case. If I am right then our internet culture is not only a tool for us but it is changing us and we may not like what we are changing into. Perhaps being online merely allows us to express our human nature which may have a natural tendency to denigrate those we disagree with. Regardless, we would be wise to continue to monitor our online culture and be aware of how it may change us or reveal who we really are.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Friday, March 23, 2012
Bullying
I have a confession to make. When I was a young kid I was the victim of bullying. I was pretty small kid and could be pushed around. I also lacked confidence and kids tend to like to pick on those who lack confidence. It does not seem very masculine to admit that you were pushed around as a child. I guess that is why I do not talk that much about it.
Perhaps that is why I found it interesting all of the recent movement for the end of bullying. I can relate to the effects bullying can have on a kid. If there is a reasonable way we can cut down on bullying then by all means we should look at it. Is it possible that trouble-maker and Lady Gaga can agree on something?
Well not so much. It seems that all the activity against bullying is concentrated on one motivation for bullying. That is the bullying due to sexual preference. In other words it is about bullying people because of a perception or reality that they are homosexual. All of this activity would not have mattered one bit when I was a kid since that was not the reason for my torment. It seems that the new bully activists do not really care about what kids go through unless it is because of their sexual preference.
But the problem is deeper than that. Such anti-bullying activity could actually support more bullying. We could be creating an atmosphere that those who are deemed not accepting enough of homosexuality could find themselves the targets of different types of bullying. It may not be from other kids as much as it is from authorities. They may target those who are not PC enough on issues of sexual preference and differentially punish those who are deemed guilty of bullying homosexuals.
Think I am exaggerating? Take the case of Dharun Ravi. That is the Rutgers student who was found guilty for using a webcam on his roommate having sex with another man. His roommate killed himself due to this embarrassment. Ravi may get as much as ten years of prison for his crime and is likely to be deported. Was this stupid? Yes. Does he deserve to be punished? Absolutely. I am thinking suspension from college for a semester or so seems like an appropriate punishment. But ten years!!!! We all know of stupid and insensitive college pranks that should be punished. Fortunately most of us have not done such pranks against homosexuals. I believe that if Ravi had done his thoughtless prank with a heterosexual roommate he would have gotten a more appropriate punishment. The authorities have stepped in and upped the punishment greatly which sends a signal on who can and who cannot be bullied.
We really do need an anti-bullying movement in our society. A true anti-bullying movement would address bullying no matter what the motivation for the bullying. It would not classify some victims as more worthy of protection than others. We should not trade one form of bullying for another. Doing so will not decrease bullying but merely change its target. Ironically it is possible that the anti-bullying movement’s focus on sexual preference may have the net effect of increasing bullying in the United States.
I know what it is like to be the bottom kid on the totem pole. The fact that it was not because of my sexual preference did not make it more pleasant for me. Finding out why kids bullying each other and learning how to discourage bullying is a laudable goal. Let’s make it a benefit for all kids who are bullied and not merely for those who are bullied for politically correct reasons.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Perhaps that is why I found it interesting all of the recent movement for the end of bullying. I can relate to the effects bullying can have on a kid. If there is a reasonable way we can cut down on bullying then by all means we should look at it. Is it possible that trouble-maker and Lady Gaga can agree on something?
Well not so much. It seems that all the activity against bullying is concentrated on one motivation for bullying. That is the bullying due to sexual preference. In other words it is about bullying people because of a perception or reality that they are homosexual. All of this activity would not have mattered one bit when I was a kid since that was not the reason for my torment. It seems that the new bully activists do not really care about what kids go through unless it is because of their sexual preference.
But the problem is deeper than that. Such anti-bullying activity could actually support more bullying. We could be creating an atmosphere that those who are deemed not accepting enough of homosexuality could find themselves the targets of different types of bullying. It may not be from other kids as much as it is from authorities. They may target those who are not PC enough on issues of sexual preference and differentially punish those who are deemed guilty of bullying homosexuals.
Think I am exaggerating? Take the case of Dharun Ravi. That is the Rutgers student who was found guilty for using a webcam on his roommate having sex with another man. His roommate killed himself due to this embarrassment. Ravi may get as much as ten years of prison for his crime and is likely to be deported. Was this stupid? Yes. Does he deserve to be punished? Absolutely. I am thinking suspension from college for a semester or so seems like an appropriate punishment. But ten years!!!! We all know of stupid and insensitive college pranks that should be punished. Fortunately most of us have not done such pranks against homosexuals. I believe that if Ravi had done his thoughtless prank with a heterosexual roommate he would have gotten a more appropriate punishment. The authorities have stepped in and upped the punishment greatly which sends a signal on who can and who cannot be bullied.
We really do need an anti-bullying movement in our society. A true anti-bullying movement would address bullying no matter what the motivation for the bullying. It would not classify some victims as more worthy of protection than others. We should not trade one form of bullying for another. Doing so will not decrease bullying but merely change its target. Ironically it is possible that the anti-bullying movement’s focus on sexual preference may have the net effect of increasing bullying in the United States.
I know what it is like to be the bottom kid on the totem pole. The fact that it was not because of my sexual preference did not make it more pleasant for me. Finding out why kids bullying each other and learning how to discourage bullying is a laudable goal. Let’s make it a benefit for all kids who are bullied and not merely for those who are bullied for politically correct reasons.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Tuesday, March 13, 2012
GCB
Okay I have heard that the new show GCB had anti-Christian overtones. So I felt obigated to watch it and see for myself. Boy was that a waste of my life.
Was there some anti-Christian overtones? Maybe a little. It seems to me that the Christian characters on the show are not very likeable. But then again none of the charcters on that show are very likeable. Therein is the crux of the matter. The show is awful. I could not get through the entire pilot. I do not know how anyone can stand to watch that sort of drivel.
I accept the fact that there is anti-Christian bias in Hollywood that comes out in protrayals of Christians. Can you remember the last time there was a sympathetic overtly Christian character in Hollywood? Perhaps GCB was an attempt to express this bias. But it simply was not a good enough vehicle to do so. The characters were so cardboard and one dimensional that no thinking person can take the show seriously.
So put me on the anti-GCB bandwagon. Not becasue I think the show is a great example of anti-Christian bigotry. But because we already have enough bad TV shows and we do not need any more.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Was there some anti-Christian overtones? Maybe a little. It seems to me that the Christian characters on the show are not very likeable. But then again none of the charcters on that show are very likeable. Therein is the crux of the matter. The show is awful. I could not get through the entire pilot. I do not know how anyone can stand to watch that sort of drivel.
I accept the fact that there is anti-Christian bias in Hollywood that comes out in protrayals of Christians. Can you remember the last time there was a sympathetic overtly Christian character in Hollywood? Perhaps GCB was an attempt to express this bias. But it simply was not a good enough vehicle to do so. The characters were so cardboard and one dimensional that no thinking person can take the show seriously.
So put me on the anti-GCB bandwagon. Not becasue I think the show is a great example of anti-Christian bigotry. But because we already have enough bad TV shows and we do not need any more.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Saturday, March 3, 2012
A Test for Conservatives
You probably have heard about the Rush Limbaugh and Sandra Fluke controversy by now. If you have not then here is an ABC article to provide you a quick update.
http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2012/03/rush-limbaugh-sandra-fluke-a-slut-and-prostitute/
So Limbaugh has not only refused to apologize but he has also made his insults of Fluke worse. Nice.
The sad part is that I agree that Fluke had no business testifying in a hearing on religious rights. I heard her before Limbaugh got involved and she struck me as another student steeped in entitlement thinking. Here is a clue. If you go to a Catholic college then do not expect them to supply you with contraceptives. Go somewhere else if that is important to you. But none of that entitlement thinking excuses the disgusting behavior of Limbaugh. The points I just made could have been made without dragging this argument through the mud. Limbaugh should be ashamed of himself.
Now is the time for conservatives to disown Limbaugh. He has had his day. I give him credit for being the first major player in the, at that time, new area of talk radio. And in his heyday he did it quite well. I did not agree with him a good deal of the time but he was entertaining and could persuade me to rethink things. What he is doing now is neither entertaining nor insightful. It is just crude. His day has passed and it is time for him to go.
But will conservatives facilitate reducing his exit or at least reduce his current influence? I remember when John McCain dared to criticize Limbaugh during his presidential run. The backlash he received from that criticism made McCain backtrack in a hurry. Limbaugh has made himself the third rail of conservative politics. You do not criticize him without consequence in the conservative community.
But conservatives who care about their causes need to face down Limbaugh. It is not as if there are not other talented conservative commentators who can carry on in the talk radio arena that conservatives dominate so well. I have criticized progressives who do not police their own extremists. At this point Limbaugh is an extremist who has taken an issue of religious freedom and reduced it down to name-calling.
This is the test for conservatives to see who is brave enough to openly challenge him and condemn Limbaugh. I say condemn Limbaugh because it is not enough to just condemn the comments. You also have to condemn the man who is unrepentant about those comments. For too long Limbaugh has been treated with kid gloves by conservatives. Will any conservatives have the wisdom to see that his day has past and the guts to marginalize him in their conservative subculture? Praise him for his historical breakthroughs if you must and acknowledge his previous accomplishments. But please do not enable him to infect us with more venomous comments in the future. Those of us who are not conservatives, and especially us moderates who can be won to some of your causes from time to time, will be watching conservatives to see if they have the spine to do what is right.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2012/03/rush-limbaugh-sandra-fluke-a-slut-and-prostitute/
So Limbaugh has not only refused to apologize but he has also made his insults of Fluke worse. Nice.
The sad part is that I agree that Fluke had no business testifying in a hearing on religious rights. I heard her before Limbaugh got involved and she struck me as another student steeped in entitlement thinking. Here is a clue. If you go to a Catholic college then do not expect them to supply you with contraceptives. Go somewhere else if that is important to you. But none of that entitlement thinking excuses the disgusting behavior of Limbaugh. The points I just made could have been made without dragging this argument through the mud. Limbaugh should be ashamed of himself.
Now is the time for conservatives to disown Limbaugh. He has had his day. I give him credit for being the first major player in the, at that time, new area of talk radio. And in his heyday he did it quite well. I did not agree with him a good deal of the time but he was entertaining and could persuade me to rethink things. What he is doing now is neither entertaining nor insightful. It is just crude. His day has passed and it is time for him to go.
But will conservatives facilitate reducing his exit or at least reduce his current influence? I remember when John McCain dared to criticize Limbaugh during his presidential run. The backlash he received from that criticism made McCain backtrack in a hurry. Limbaugh has made himself the third rail of conservative politics. You do not criticize him without consequence in the conservative community.
But conservatives who care about their causes need to face down Limbaugh. It is not as if there are not other talented conservative commentators who can carry on in the talk radio arena that conservatives dominate so well. I have criticized progressives who do not police their own extremists. At this point Limbaugh is an extremist who has taken an issue of religious freedom and reduced it down to name-calling.
This is the test for conservatives to see who is brave enough to openly challenge him and condemn Limbaugh. I say condemn Limbaugh because it is not enough to just condemn the comments. You also have to condemn the man who is unrepentant about those comments. For too long Limbaugh has been treated with kid gloves by conservatives. Will any conservatives have the wisdom to see that his day has past and the guts to marginalize him in their conservative subculture? Praise him for his historical breakthroughs if you must and acknowledge his previous accomplishments. But please do not enable him to infect us with more venomous comments in the future. Those of us who are not conservatives, and especially us moderates who can be won to some of your causes from time to time, will be watching conservatives to see if they have the spine to do what is right.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Friday, March 2, 2012
To a new low in rhetoric.
Well this is a new low in political rhetoric. I support free speech and their right to be crude. But I still ask why can we not do better than this?
http://news.yahoo.com/hell-barack-row-over-washington-metro-ad-051919392.html
What is gained by such an insult to the President? When did we lose our manners? Can we not agree without being disagreeable? All this does is entice those on the other side to stoop to insults as well. No wonder why those of us who are not fully in the Republican or Democrat camp are not always eager to go out and vote. I guess we better or we will let the extremists decide our elections.
I wish I had some super powerful insight here. But to me it just seems like a bunch of children got some money and decided to insult the President. Already I want this political season to end.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
http://news.yahoo.com/hell-barack-row-over-washington-metro-ad-051919392.html
What is gained by such an insult to the President? When did we lose our manners? Can we not agree without being disagreeable? All this does is entice those on the other side to stoop to insults as well. No wonder why those of us who are not fully in the Republican or Democrat camp are not always eager to go out and vote. I guess we better or we will let the extremists decide our elections.
I wish I had some super powerful insight here. But to me it just seems like a bunch of children got some money and decided to insult the President. Already I want this political season to end.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Thursday, February 23, 2012
Tebow or Lin?
It is amazing the reception that Jeremy Lin has gotten. So much so that I think I need another blog about him. That is two in a row on Lin, which is something that I did not do for Tim Tebow. In fact the comparison of Lin to Tebow is quite interesting.
Both Lin and Tebow were almost overnight media sensations. It is probably fair to say that both got more coverage than they deserved. But both are helping a team to win that was not winning before they took over their starting positions. And both are evangelical Christians. These are the similarities between the two athletes.
But there is a critical observable difference. Tebow came with a great deal of controversy. It is fair to say that at times it seems that as many people hated Tebow as loved him. His detractors were legion and it was not just because of his football skills, or lack thereof. Some commentators and football players took shots at his faith as well. There has been some controversy generated by Lin but it has not been widely supported. For example, everybody condemned the controversy over the “Armor” comment featured on ESPN. Nobody defended it and an editor was fired over it. When Saturday Night Live decided to mock Tebow with a skit in which a fake Jesus criticizes him, there was not an equivalent outburst and no one was fired. Furthermore, Tebow has inspired t-shirts and a facebook page dedicated to hating him. There is no doubt that Tebow has produced more antipathy than Lin and it is not even close.
Why this difference? I have a theory. In a divided country we look for clues that indicate whether it is allowable to support a certain person. Tebow, as Lin, is an open evangelical Christian. That signals to religious, and even political, conservatives that Tebow is someone that can be supported. But there is nothing about Tebow for progressives to support unless they are a fan of the Florida Gators or Denver Broncos. So such progressives feel free to hate him.
Lin is also an evangelical. But he is also an Asian-American breaking into a field where Asians and Asian-Americans are relatively rare. This has the imagery of a racial minority conquering new territory and this image is welcoming to political progressives. So in addition to his obvious appeal to Asian-American fans that image also provides a cue for progressives to accept him as well.
I like Lin. I am quite happy for his success. He is fun to watch and I tend to root for him, as long as he is not playing my Spurs. But I have to wonder if he would be getting so much love if he was just another white or black ballplayer. I would wonder if his faith would create the level of controversy that we saw with Tebow. I am not blaming progressives here. I do not think that conservatives would support Tebow and Lin to the extent that they do if they were not evangelical Christians. But we live in a culturally divided society and the different fate of Tebow and Lin illustrates this.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Both Lin and Tebow were almost overnight media sensations. It is probably fair to say that both got more coverage than they deserved. But both are helping a team to win that was not winning before they took over their starting positions. And both are evangelical Christians. These are the similarities between the two athletes.
But there is a critical observable difference. Tebow came with a great deal of controversy. It is fair to say that at times it seems that as many people hated Tebow as loved him. His detractors were legion and it was not just because of his football skills, or lack thereof. Some commentators and football players took shots at his faith as well. There has been some controversy generated by Lin but it has not been widely supported. For example, everybody condemned the controversy over the “Armor” comment featured on ESPN. Nobody defended it and an editor was fired over it. When Saturday Night Live decided to mock Tebow with a skit in which a fake Jesus criticizes him, there was not an equivalent outburst and no one was fired. Furthermore, Tebow has inspired t-shirts and a facebook page dedicated to hating him. There is no doubt that Tebow has produced more antipathy than Lin and it is not even close.
Why this difference? I have a theory. In a divided country we look for clues that indicate whether it is allowable to support a certain person. Tebow, as Lin, is an open evangelical Christian. That signals to religious, and even political, conservatives that Tebow is someone that can be supported. But there is nothing about Tebow for progressives to support unless they are a fan of the Florida Gators or Denver Broncos. So such progressives feel free to hate him.
Lin is also an evangelical. But he is also an Asian-American breaking into a field where Asians and Asian-Americans are relatively rare. This has the imagery of a racial minority conquering new territory and this image is welcoming to political progressives. So in addition to his obvious appeal to Asian-American fans that image also provides a cue for progressives to accept him as well.
I like Lin. I am quite happy for his success. He is fun to watch and I tend to root for him, as long as he is not playing my Spurs. But I have to wonder if he would be getting so much love if he was just another white or black ballplayer. I would wonder if his faith would create the level of controversy that we saw with Tebow. I am not blaming progressives here. I do not think that conservatives would support Tebow and Lin to the extent that they do if they were not evangelical Christians. But we live in a culturally divided society and the different fate of Tebow and Lin illustrates this.
Sincerely,
Trouble-Maker
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)